In this episode of Man vs. Copilot, hosts Amelia Roberts and Greg Trzeciak tackle the common workplace dilemma of responding to a difficult email from a boss. They dive into the capabilities of Microsoft's Copilot for Outlook, putting the AI tool to the test in comparison with traditional human email crafting. Here’s a recap of their friendly competition, offering tips on how to navigate tricky emails and using technology to enhance productivity.

The Challenge: A Boss’s Frustrating Email

The email from the fictional boss, Brian, sets the stage for the challenge. Brian’s tone is frustrated and demands quick action on a project that is falling behind. He asks for a detailed action plan by Wednesday, with weekly updates moving forward. The hosts need to reply appropriately, handling the boss's angry tone while maintaining professionalism.

The scenario presents several hurdles:

• A tense, urgent tone from the boss.
• Clear expectations but little room for excuses.
• The challenge of responding quickly and professionally.

The Human Approach: Greg’s Attempt

Greg takes the traditional route, crafting his response manually. He begins by acknowledging the frustration of the situation and tries to provide a professional yet apologetic tone. His draft includes:

• Acknowledging the delay on the project.
• Offering a commitment to work through lunch if necessary to get the action plan ready.
• Setting up a Teams meeting and scheduling reminders for weekly updates.

However, Greg struggles with balancing tone and ensuring all action items are addressed. His focus is on being neutral and not directly blaming anyone, especially not Amelia, even though he is competing against her. He finishes with an apology for the inconvenience and signs off in a respectful manner.

Greg’s Self-Assessment:

• Accuracy: Greg feels he hit most of the points but isn’t sure if he addressed everything clearly.
• Speed: Greg is concerned about the time it took to draft the email, fearing it would not be fast enough.
• Creativity in Tone: Greg keeps his response neutral but is unsure if it’s positive or creative enough to appease his boss.

The AI Approach: Amelia’s Copilot

Amelia, on the other hand, decides to use Copilot in Outlook. She opens a new email draft and uses Copilot to generate a professional, reassuring response. Her approach includes:

• Assuring Brian that she has the skills and expertise to handle the project.
• Offering to schedule a kickoff meeting to align on the project’s objectives.
• Inviting Brian to provide any specific concerns for further discussion.

Amelia also uses Copilot’s ability to analyze and provide suggestions on improving the tone, making it more positive and appreciative. She then takes her AI-generated draft and refines it further, making sure to include:

• A mention of the team’s commitment to working together.
• A schedule for a Teams meeting, directly integrating Outlook’s features for smooth coordination.

Copilot’s Strengths

Amelia highlights several features of Copilot that help make her email better:

• Tone Refinement: Copilot suggests more positive language, turning phrases like “totally understand” into “I understand the delay” and replacing vague wording with clearer, more specific details.
• Efficiency: Copilot helps Amelia generate and refine a draft in a matter of seconds, making the process faster and less anxiety-inducing.
• Integrated Scheduling: Amelia uses Copilot to schedule the required Teams meeting directly from within Outlook, showcasing the integration of AI with Outlook’s calendar functions.

The Comparison: Who Wins?

After both hosts send their drafts, they assess their responses based on three key criteria:

• Accuracy: Amelia’s use of Copilot ensured that she addressed every point raised by Brian, including the action plan, the meeting schedule, and weekly updates.
• Speed: Amelia’s use of Copilot significantly outpaced Greg, as she completed the email in a fraction of the time.
• Creativity in Tone: Amelia’s response, polished by Copilot, was more positive and professional, with a tone that reassured Brian that the project was in good hands.

Final Verdict: Although Greg did his best, the clear winner is Amelia, thanks to Copilot’s ability to streamline the email creation process, maintain a professional tone, and ensure all points are addressed.

Key Takeaways for Email Responses in the Workplace

• Acknowledge the Situation Clearly: Always acknowledge the issue at hand. It shows that you understand the urgency and are taking it seriously.
• Maintain a Professional Tone: It’s important to remain calm and professional, especially when responding to a frustrated boss.
• Use Technology Wisely: Tools like Copilot for Outlook can help ensure accuracy, save time, and help improve the tone of your emails, especially when the stakes are high.
• Be Specific and Action-Oriented: Always address action items and deadlines directly. Ensure your response is clear and that it meets the boss’s expectations.

By leveraging these strategies, both human and AI responses can effectively navigate tough email scenarios and lead to better outcomes.

Don't forget to check out the Pragmatic Works' on-demand learning platform for more insightful content and training sessions on Copilot and other Microsoft applications. Be sure to subscribe to the Pragmatic Works YouTube channel to stay up-to-date on the latest tips and tricks.